No Upfront Payment Required: Start your valuation journey with ease.
Risk-Free Service Guarantee: We stand by our expertise and quality.
Customized Detail: Receive a comprehensive, 50+ page business valuation report, tailored to your specific needs and signed by our expert evaluators.
Prompt Delivery: Expect your detailed report within five working days.
Rollover as Business Startups (ROBS) arrangements offer entrepreneurs a unique opportunity to use retirement funds to finance a new business without incurring early withdrawal taxes or penalties. However, one critical aspect of a ROBS transaction is the Business Valuation. The value of the new company’s stock — purchased by your 401(k) plan as part of the ROBS setup — must be determined fairly and accurately. If the Business Valuation is too low (undervalued), it can trigger serious problems with the IRS and other legal complications. In this article, we delve into why a low valuation in a ROBS structure is problematic, what IRS regulations say about it, and the risks and consequences involved. We also provide guidance on how to address an undervalued ROBS business and maintain compliance, with insights for both small business owners and financial professionals. Finally, we highlight how SimplyBusinessValuation.com can help navigate these complex valuation issues and ensure your ROBS stays on the right side of the law.
Accurate valuation isn’t just a formality – it’s a legal requirement. The IRS mandates that any business purchased or funded with retirement plan assets must be fairly valued (Valuing a Company for Rollover as Business Startups (ROBS) Purposes). In a ROBS transaction, that means your 401(k) plan should buy stock in the new corporation at a price reflecting the true fair market value of the business. Undervaluing the business may lead to IRS scrutiny (Valuing a Company for Rollover as Business Startups (ROBS) Purposes), as the IRS sees an incorrectly low valuation as a potential abuse of tax-deferred retirement funds. The concern is that some ROBS setups have artificially low valuations simply to fit the amount of available retirement money, rather than reflecting what the business is genuinely worth. If the valuation is too low, the transaction might not meet legal requirements for “adequate consideration,” opening the door to severe tax and legal consequences.
The IRS even launched a compliance project and found that a majority of ROBS setups had significant defects or ended up in business failure (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service). To avoid that fate, it's crucial to understand the rules and get your valuation right from the start. In the sections that follow, we provide an in-depth analysis of IRS regulations surrounding ROBS valuations and explain exactly why an undervalued business can spell trouble. We’ll outline the key risks — from tax penalties to plan disqualification — and what they mean for you as a business owner or advisor. You’ll also learn practical steps to fix or prevent a low valuation problem, ensuring your ROBS arrangement remains compliant. Throughout, we cite authoritative U.S. sources like IRS regulations and guidance to back up the information, so you can trust the accuracy of what you’re reading. By the end of this article, you should have a clear understanding of what happens if the Business Valuation is too low in a ROBS, and how SimplyBusinessValuation.com can serve as a resource to help you navigate these challenges.
Before diving into the complications of a low valuation, let’s briefly recap what a ROBS arrangement entails and why valuation plays such a pivotal role. ROBS (Rollover as Business Startups) is a financing method that allows you to roll over funds from a qualified retirement plan (such as a 401(k) or traditional IRA) into a new business venture. The mechanism works like this: you create a new C Corporation for your business, set up a new 401(k) plan under that corporation, and roll your existing retirement funds into the new plan. The new 401(k) plan then invests in the business by purchasing stock in your C Corporation (Rollovers for Business Startups ROBS FAQ - Guidant). In effect, your retirement plan becomes a shareholder of your company, and the company gains cash to operate (coming from your rolled-over retirement money).
This structure is legal and recognized by the IRS, but it is subject to very specific rules and regulations. One key requirement is that the transaction must be for “adequate consideration,” meaning the price your retirement plan pays for the stock must reflect the stock’s fair market value. In simpler terms, your 401(k) should buy shares in your new company for a price that an independent, willing buyer would pay — no more and no less. Accurate Business Valuation, therefore, is at the heart of the ROBS arrangement. It determines how many shares your plan will receive in exchange for the rolled-over funds and ensures that neither the retirement plan nor the business is getting a “sweetheart deal” at the expense of the other.
Why is this so important? Because if the valuation is off — especially if it’s set too low — the IRS could view the stock purchase as a prohibited transaction. Remember, normally a retirement plan investing in an employer’s company stock can be a prohibited transaction (since it’s essentially a deal between a plan and its beneficiary/employer). ROBS transactions rely on an exemption to the prohibited transaction rules: specifically, the plan’s purchase of “qualifying employer securities” (the stock of your new company) is allowed only if it’s done at fair market value (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups) (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). The Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) provides this exemption under ERISA § 408(e), but it explicitly requires paying adequate consideration (fair market value) for the stock. If you fail that test — say, by issuing stock to your 401(k) at a price that’s unreasonably low — then the transaction loses its protected status and is treated as a prohibited transaction in the eyes of the law (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups).
In practical terms, an accurate valuation ensures that your retirement plan doesn’t pay too little or too much for the business. Overpaying is harmful to your retirement savings (your 401(k) would be buying stock at an inflated price, diminishing its value), while underpaying (undervaluing the company) can trigger regulatory red flags (Valuing a Company for Rollover as Business Startups (ROBS) Purposes). Getting the valuation right is a balancing act that protects all parties: it protects your retirement assets, treats the plan fairly, and demonstrates to the IRS that you’re following the rules. That’s why typically a qualified independent appraisal is recommended when setting up a ROBS (Valuing a Company for Rollover as Business Startups (ROBS) Purposes). A professional business valuator will use standard valuation methodologies (income approach, market comparables, asset-based approach) to determine what your startup is truly worth, even if it’s a brand-new business with no history. This thorough appraisal process documents the basis for the stock price, which is critical evidence of compliance.
If you’re a small business owner considering a ROBS, or a CPA/financial advisor helping a client through one, never underestimate the importance of fair valuation. It is literally the foundation that keeps the ROBS compliant. In the next section, we’ll delve deeper into the IRS regulations that govern ROBS valuations and explain exactly what could go wrong if a business is undervalued in this context.
The IRS has kept a close eye on ROBS arrangements for years, precisely because they walk a fine line between legitimate financing and potential abuse. In 2008, the IRS issued a detailed memorandum outlining compliance guidelines for ROBS plans (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups) (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). While the IRS did not declare ROBS inherently illegal (they’re “not considered an abusive tax avoidance transaction”), the agency flagged them as “questionable” and began a compliance project to identify issues (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service) (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service). One of the top issues identified was the valuation of the stock (assets) in these transactions (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service) (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service).
According to IRS regulations and ERISA provisions, when your retirement plan (the 401(k) in the ROBS) buys stock in your company, that purchase must be done at fair market value. This is sometimes referred to as the “adequate consideration” requirement. Legally, the basis for this is found in ERISA § 408(e) and the Internal Revenue Code § 4975(d)(13). These sections create an exemption to the usual prohibited transaction rules, allowing the plan to invest in the employer’s company stock if and only if the transaction is for adequate consideration (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). And since your new startup’s stock isn’t publicly traded (no established market price), “adequate consideration” means a price that reflects the fair market value of the stock as determined in good faith by plan fiduciaries (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups).
In plain English, the IRS expects that you treat your retirement plan just like any other investor who deserves a fair deal. You can’t sell shares to your 401(k) at a token price that’s arbitrarily low just to use up your retirement funds conveniently. Nor should you assign an inflated value. The price needs to be justified by what the business is worth at the time of the transaction. This is where an independent appraisal comes in as evidence. The IRS guidelines note that valuation of the new company’s capitalization is a “relevant issue” in every ROBS because, being new, it’s not obvious what the company is worth (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). A new startup often has minimal assets initially (perhaps just the cash being rolled over and maybe some intangible value like a business plan). So, there is naturally a question: is the company really worth the full amount of the retirement funds being invested, or is that valuation just set to match the available 401(k) balance? If the latter, the IRS gets concerned that the valuation isn’t “bona fide.”
The IRS compliance project found that in many ROBS setups, the valuation was essentially an afterthought. In fact, IRS examiners reported being given very minimal valuation documentation — sometimes just a single piece of paper from a “valuation specialist” claiming the company’s stock was worth exactly the amount of the rolled-over funds (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). It doesn’t take much for the IRS to see that as a red flag. If every ROBS business magically is valued precisely at, say, $150,000 because that’s what the entrepreneur had in their IRA, it looks suspicious. The IRS memorandum explicitly calls these appraisals “questionable” when they merely mirror the available retirement account balance (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). Why? Because it suggests there was no real analysis of the business’s value — the number was driven by how much money was on hand, not economic reality.
To enforce compliance, the IRS has the power to scrutinize these valuations. The agency’s ROBS compliance initiative sends out questionnaires asking for details like how the stock price was determined (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service). If audited, you would need to show the methodology and basis for your valuation. Did you consider the business’s assets, its earning potential, comparables in the market? If the IRS finds the valuation was “deficient” — meaning unsupported or just plain too low or too high without justification — it can trigger consequences. The primary concern, as mentioned, is that an undervalued sale of stock to the plan could be a prohibited transaction (because the plan didn’t get a fair deal). It could also raise questions of plan qualification and discrimination if it appears the whole plan was set up just to benefit you as the owner with no regard for other employees (more on that later).
In summary, IRS regulations insist on fair market valuation in ROBS transactions. The legal groundwork is that the 401(k) plan’s purchase of the company stock must satisfy the adequate consideration standard of ERISA and the tax code. The IRS has explicitly warned that improper valuations — especially undervaluation — are a serious compliance issue. So, a too-low valuation doesn’t just slip under the radar as a harmless mistake; it goes to the heart of whether your ROBS arrangement follows the rules or not.
When the Business Valuation for a ROBS is too low, it means your retirement plan is buying shares of the company at a bargain price relative to what they’re really worth. On the surface, one might think the retirement plan (and thus you, indirectly) benefits from a low price — after all, your 401(k) gets more equity for the money. But in the eyes of the law, this scenario is problematic for several reasons:
It violates the “adequate consideration” requirement: As discussed, the only thing making a ROBS transaction legal is the condition that your plan pays a fair price for the stock. If you undervalue the company, you’re failing that requirement (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). The transaction is no longer shielded by the exemption and can be treated as a prohibited transaction. Essentially, an undervalued sale is viewed as the plan (your 401(k)) and the company (you as the owner) doing a deal that isn’t arm’s-length. The IRS and Department of Labor consider that a breach of fiduciary duty because the plan wasn’t treated fairly.
Prohibited transaction concerns: A prohibited transaction is a big deal. Under Internal Revenue Code § 4975, prohibited transactions between a retirement plan and “disqualified persons” (which includes the business owner and the company itself) are subject to heavy penalties. The IRS has explicitly pointed out that ROBS arrangements can lead to prohibited transactions if the stock valuation is deficient (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups) (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). If your low valuation means the plan paid, say, $50,000 for stock that was really worth $100,000, then effectively the plan didn’t get a fair deal. That’s akin to the company (which you control) giving a half-priced bargain to the plan. It sounds odd—since both are essentially “yours”—but the law treats the plan as a separate entity whose assets must be handled prudently. Any sale or exchange of property between the plan and a disqualified person is forbidden by default (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups), unless the adequate consideration exemption applies. Undervaluation blows that exemption, so the transaction becomes prohibited.
IRS scrutiny and audits: Even before formal penalties come into play, an unusually low valuation is practically an invitation for IRS scrutiny. As noted earlier, the IRS found many ROBS plans where the stock value conveniently equaled the available retirement funds (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). They’ve indicated that such cases raise a “question as to whether the entire exchange is a prohibited transaction” (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). This means if you ever get audited or go through a compliance check, the agent will likely zero in on how you valued the business. It’s not hard for them to spot issues: if your company had no operations, minimal assets, and yet you claimed it was worth exactly $200,000 because you had $200,000 in your IRA, eyebrows will rise. IRS scrutiny can lead to a full examination of your plan, during which they might find other issues, but the valuation will be the cornerstone of the investigation.
Plan disqualification risk: If the valuation problem is egregious, the IRS could determine that your entire plan does not qualify as a legitimate retirement plan due to disqualifying defects (the undervalued transaction being one such defect). The IRS has the power to disqualify a retirement plan retroactively if it fails to meet the requirements of the law. The 2008 IRS memo on ROBS noted that a number of these plans had “significant disqualifying operational defects” (Using ROBS to Cash in Your 401k Is Risky Business - Newsweek). What does disqualification mean? In short, very bad news: the plan’s tax-deferred status is revoked, and it’s as if your rollover never happened properly. We’ll cover the tax implications of that in the next section, but suffice it to say it could result in back taxes and penalties for you personally.
Violation of fiduciary duties and ERISA rules: In a ROBS, you as the business owner often serve as a fiduciary of the new 401(k) plan (because you’re typically the trustee or plan administrator as well). As a fiduciary, you have a legal duty to act in the best interests of the plan’s participants (which might just be you, but legally it could include others). Selling stock to the plan at an unfair price (too low or too high) is a breach of those duties. ERISA requires plan fiduciaries to act prudently and solely in the interest of plan participants. Causing the plan to engage in a transaction at other than fair market value is basically a breach, which is why it’s categorized under prohibited transactions. Not only could the IRS come after you, but the Department of Labor (which enforces ERISA) could also potentially investigate, since ERISA’s fiduciary standards and prohibited transaction rules are at play. The IRS memo explicitly mentions that lack of a bona fide appraisal calls into question the legitimacy of the whole exchange (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups), implying a fiduciary lapse as well.
Undervaluation might seem trivial, but as these consequences show, any short-term convenience can lead to long-term pain. The cost of non-compliance easily dwarfs the effort of doing things right upfront. Truly, it’s just not worth the risk at all.
In essence, an undervalued business in a ROBS is a ticking time bomb. It undermines the very conditions that allow the ROBS to exist legally. What might seem like a handy way to maximize the use of your retirement funds can backfire disastrously if the IRS deems your valuation was too low. The next section explores the consequences of such a scenario: what taxes, penalties, or legal outcomes result if the IRS says your ROBS valuation failed the test.
What exactly can happen if the IRS discovers that your ROBS stock purchase was based on an excessively low valuation? The consequences can range from financial penalties to the unwinding of the entire ROBS arrangement. Let’s break down the main tax implications and enforcement actions:
1. Prohibited Transaction Taxes (Excise Taxes): If the undervaluation causes the stock purchase to be a prohibited transaction, the IRS can impose excise taxes under Internal Revenue Code § 4975. The initial tax is 15% of the “amount involved” in the transaction (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). The “amount involved” would likely be the difference between what the stock was really worth and what the plan paid (or perhaps the total amount that was misused). For example, if the plan paid $100,000 for stock that was worth $200,000, the amount involved might be $200,000 (since the plan should have paid that to get stock of that value). A 15% excise tax on $200,000 is $30,000 — not a trivial sum. But it gets worse: if the transaction is not corrected promptly, the tax can jump to 100% of the amount involved (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). Yes, you read that right — a full dollar-for-dollar penalty essentially. This is a punitive measure to strongly discourage people from engaging in prohibited transactions. The law gives a chance to correct the issue (more on correction in a moment), but if you don’t fix it within the “taxable period,” the IRS can hit you with the 100% tax, which in our example would be $200,000. That’s effectively confiscatory.
Who pays these taxes? Generally, the “disqualified person” who participated in the prohibited transaction is liable. In a ROBS context, that could be the plan fiduciary (often you) or the corporation. The corporation is a disqualified person in relation to the plan, and you as a 50%+ owner are also a disqualified person (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). So the IRS could assess the excise tax against whichever entity makes sense under the rules (often it would fall on the person who caused the transaction, which would likely be you as the plan sponsor who approved the stock sale).
2. Requirement to Correct the Transaction: The IRS doesn’t just tax you and leave the bad transaction in place. Under the prohibited transaction rules, there’s an expectation (and requirement) that you correct the transaction to undo the damage (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups) (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). In the case of an undervalued stock sale, correction typically means the corporation (your business) must make it right by the plan. The IRS memo gives an example solution: the company would have to redeem the stock from the plan and replace it with cash equal to the stock’s fair market value, plus interest to compensate the plan for any lost earnings (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). This essentially unwinds the transaction as if the plan had gotten cash for what it should have gotten in the first place. In practice, this could be very difficult — if you had the cash to do that, you might not have needed to do a ROBS to begin with. Nonetheless, that’s the corrective action expected: make the plan whole as if it had been treated fairly initially.
If you complete the correction in time (typically before the IRS finalizes the 15% tax assessment or before they issue a notice of deficiency), you can avoid the 100% tax. But you’d still owe the 15% excise tax for having done it in the first place. Plus, coming up with the correction money can strain or bankrupt the company if the amount is large.
3. Plan Disqualification and Income Taxes: Beyond the excise taxes, a larger looming threat is plan disqualification. If the IRS determines your plan isn’t operating within the rules (due to the prohibited transaction or other ROBS issues), they can disqualify the plan retroactively. Disqualification has a cascade of tax consequences:
The trust (plan) loses its tax-exempt status retroactively. This means from the start of the disqualification period, the plan is treated as a normal taxable entity. Any income or gains in the plan could become taxable. More significantly for you, the rollover of funds from your old retirement account into this plan could be treated as a taxable distribution.
If your rollover is deemed invalid, you as the individual who did it might suddenly owe income tax on that amount (because it’s as if you withdrew it from your IRA/401(k) and never put it into a valid qualified plan). For example, if you rolled $150,000 into the plan, that $150,000 could be added to your taxable income in the year of the rollover. And if you were under age 59½ at the time, it might also be subject to the 10% early distribution penalty, since the money essentially left the retirement system improperly.
Contributions made by the corporation to the plan (if any, like if you did any salary deferrals or other contributions post-setup) would become taxable to you when made, rather than remaining deferred (Tax consequences of plan disqualification | Internal Revenue Service). Typically, in a disqualification, any employer contributions in years that get disqualified have to be included in the employee’s income (Tax consequences of plan disqualification | Internal Revenue Service).
The corporation might lose deductions it took for contributions to the plan, and the trust might owe taxes on its earnings.
In short, disqualification unwinds the tax advantages: you end up having to pay taxes as though the retirement funds were never properly rolled over. This is financially devastating because people usually do ROBS to avoid paying, say, 30%–40% in taxes and penalties on a withdrawal. Disqualification basically imposes those very costs after the fact, often with interest for late payment of taxes, and potentially additional penalties. The IRS in its ROBS compliance documentation warns that plan disqualification can result in “adverse tax consequences to the plan’s sponsor and its participants” (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service). That’s putting it mildly — the entire sum that was supposed to be tax-protected could be hit with taxes and penalties.
4. Loss of Retirement Savings and Business Capital: Although not a “tax penalty” per se, it’s important to note the double financial whammy that can occur. If your ROBS blows up due to a low valuation, not only do you face taxes and penalties, but you might have also lost a portion of your retirement savings to a failed or weakened business. Many ROBS-funded businesses struggle or fail (the IRS noted high rates of business failure in ROBS arrangements (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service)), and if you add a forced unwinding or penalties on top, it could wipe out your nest egg. Some entrepreneurs have ended up bankrupt — losing the business and then owing the IRS money on top of it, a truly nightmarish scenario (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service).
5. Ongoing IRS Oversight and Restrictions: Even if things don’t reach the point of disqualification, an IRS finding of a compliance issue will put a spotlight on your plan. You may be required to enter a formal correction program. The IRS has an Employee Plans Compliance Resolution System (EPCRS) for fixing plan mistakes, but not all issues (especially egregious prohibited transactions) can be resolved through it without pain. You might have to involve the Department of Labor for prohibited transaction exemption applications if trying to clean up a mess. And moving forward, your plan will likely be on the IRS’s radar for follow-up.
In summary, the tax implications of an undervalued ROBS transaction can range from significant excise taxes (15% or even 100%) (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups), to the drastic measure of plan disqualification that triggers income taxation of what was supposed to be a tax-free rollover. The financial hit can far exceed whatever benefit one thought they were getting by gaming the valuation. And beyond taxes, there’s the potential to lose the business and retirement funds entirely in the worst-case scenario.
The fallout from a low Business Valuation in a ROBS isn’t just financial. There are broader legal consequences and compliance issues that can arise, affecting the viability of your retirement plan and business. Here we outline some of these considerations:
1. Plan Fiduciary Liability: Under ERISA (the law governing retirement plans), the individuals who manage the plan (trustees, plan administrators – often the business owner in a ROBS setup) are fiduciaries. They are personally liable for breaches of their duties. Causing the plan to engage in a transaction for less than adequate consideration is effectively a breach of the duty of loyalty and prudence. If the Department of Labor (DOL) were to investigate, they could require the fiduciary to restore any losses to the plan (similar to the IRS correction, but via ERISA enforcement). In extreme cases, fiduciaries can be barred from serving plans if they engage in misconduct. While IRS is usually the one flagging ROBS issues, DOL has jurisdiction over fiduciary violations. So an undervalued sale of stock could draw DOL’s attention, especially if a participant or someone complained. The legal consequence here is that you could be held personally responsible for making the plan whole, separate from the IRS taxes. Imagine being ordered to put tens of thousands of dollars back into the 401(k) plan because you, as trustee, caused it harm by that undervalued transaction – that’s a very real possibility under ERISA.
2. Benefits, Rights & Features Discrimination: ROBS arrangements also face scrutiny under nondiscrimination rules. Typically, a qualified retirement plan must benefit employees broadly, not just the business owner. If a ROBS transaction is set up and then the plan is quickly amended or structured so that no other employees can ever buy stock through the plan, it might flunk the “benefits, rights and features” test for nondiscrimination (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service). A very low valuation might indicate that the founder’s account got a huge chunk of equity cheaply, something not available to any other employee, which can be viewed as discriminatory. While this is a more technical retirement law issue, it adds another layer of risk — the plan could be considered not a bona fide retirement plan for employees, further justifying disqualification. The IRS specifically noted that ROBS often “solely benefit one individual – the individual who rolls over his or her existing retirement funds” (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service), which is inherently suspect. Ensuring that your plan would allow other eligible employees to participate (and even invest in stock if appropriate) helps mitigate this risk, but many ROBS entrepreneurs run owner-only businesses for some time.
3. Corporate Governance Implications: Valuing a company’s stock too low could potentially run afoul of state corporate laws as well. For instance, corporations generally must not issue stock for less than par value or for grossly inadequate consideration. If you severely undervalued your stock, technically you might have issued “watered stock,” which can create liability for shareholders or directors under some state laws. While this is usually not an immediate issue unless the business fails and creditors claim the corporation was undercapitalized, it’s a consideration. Practically, the IRS/ERISA issues are the main concern, but it underscores that proper valuation is a good corporate practice too. You want your corporate records (board resolutions, etc.) to reflect that the stock issuance to the 401(k) plan was for fair value, to avoid any challenge on that front.
4. Need for Annual Valuations and RMD Calculations: Once your 401(k) plan owns private shares of your company, you are required to value those shares at least annually (for plan accounting and participant statement purposes). If your initial valuation was questionable, subsequent valuations might also be suspect. Moreover, if you or other participants in the plan reach age 72 and must take required minimum distributions (RMDs), the plan will need to calculate the distribution amount based on the stock’s value. The Attaway Linville CPA firm, which advises on ROBS, notes that business valuations are required for calculating a ROBS shareholder’s RMD and that they provide such valuations to ensure compliance (What is a ROBS? - Attaway Linville). The point here is: undervaluation isn’t a one-time risk at startup – you must keep valuing the business interest. If you undervalue in the future (perhaps to minimize RMDs or facilitate a cheap buyout of the plan’s shares), you’d be repeating the same mistake. In fact, any changes in equity ownership down the road also have to be at fair market value, or else they could be new prohibited transactions (What is a ROBS? - Attaway Linville). Maintaining proper valuations is an ongoing fiduciary duty. If the IRS didn’t catch you the first time, but later sees an odd pattern of valuations, it could reopen the issue.
5. Planning the Exit of the ROBS (Buyout of Plan Shares): Many ROBS entrepreneurs eventually want to “buy out” their 401(k) plan’s ownership in the company so they can have full personal ownership or convert the business to an S-corp, etc. To do this, the plan must sell its shares back to you or the company at fair market value. Some may be tempted to hope the valuation at that time is low so the buyout is cheap. However, deliberately lowballing the value at exit is just as problematic as undervaluing at the start. The plan must receive adequate consideration for its shares. If the business truly declined in value, a low buyout price is fine. But if the business grew and is successful, you cannot claim it’s worth almost nothing just to reclaim your retirement money cheaply — that would be a prohibited transaction (the flip side of the initial issue, with the plan now selling too low). The correct approach is to get an independent valuation at the time of the buyout and pay the plan that fair price. If you plan ahead, you can set aside funds or profits to finance this buyout. A well-planned exit strategy will ensure the transaction is clean. Keep in mind, if the plan sells the shares at a gain, that profit stays in the 401(k) (tax-deferred), which is fine – you’re swapping one asset (stock) for another (cash) inside the plan.
By understanding these legal and compliance angles, it’s clear that a low valuation in a ROBS scenario is playing with fire. It entangles ERISA fiduciary duties, tax law, and even corporate law. The safer course is always to stick to fair market value and document how you arrived at it. If you find yourself in a position where your ROBS business may have been undervalued, the next logical question is: what can you do about it? We address that next – how to fix or mitigate an undervaluation issue.
Realizing that your ROBS-funded business was undervalued can be stressful. Perhaps you set up the ROBS through a provider that didn’t insist on a thorough appraisal, or maybe you tried to DIY the valuation and are now second-guessing it. The good news is that if you act proactively, you may be able to correct the issue or at least mitigate the damage. Here are steps and considerations for addressing a too-low valuation:
1. Obtain a Professional, Retroactive Appraisal: Your first step should be to get a qualified independent Business Valuation as soon as possible. Contact a certified business appraiser or valuation firm (such as SimplyBusinessValuation.com) to perform a detailed appraisal of your company. Explain that you need a valuation as of the date of the ROBS stock purchase (the date your plan bought the shares). A credible appraiser will gather financial data, any business plans, industry research, and come up with a fair market value for that date. It’s possible that the fair value will indeed turn out to match what you originally used — especially if essentially the company’s only asset at the time was the cash from the rollover (in many cases, a new business’s fair value is basically the cash it has). However, if the appraisal comes in higher than what the plan paid, you have concrete documentation now of how much you underpaid.
Why do this? If you are audited, being able to produce a thorough appraisal report (even if done later) is far better than having nothing or a one-pager. It shows good faith that you tried to substantiate the value. And if the valuation was clearly too low, knowing the magnitude is important for the next steps. Also, if you choose to correct the transaction (like paying money into the plan), you need to know the correct amount. An independent valuation gives you a factual basis to proceed.
2. Consult with a ROBS Compliance Expert (CPA or Attorney): Next, consult a tax attorney or CPA who has experience specifically with ROBS and plan compliance. They can guide you on the proper way to fix the issue. One possible route is through the IRS’s Voluntary Correction Program (VCP) or the DOL’s Voluntary Fiduciary Correction Program (VFCP). These programs allow plan sponsors to come forward and fix problems with less severe penalties than if caught in an audit. However, prohibited transactions are tricky to handle voluntarily. The IRS VCP might not formally sanction a correction of a prohibited transaction (they might say it’s outside their scope if excise taxes are due). The DOL’s VFCP does cover certain prohibited transactions if you correct them (it’s often discussed in context of IRAs, but similar principles can apply to 401(k) plans). An expert can help determine the best approach.
3. Correct the Transaction (Make the Plan Whole): Whether through a formal program or on your own, the ultimate goal is to correct the undervalued sale. As mentioned earlier, the IRS expects a correction like the corporation redeeming the shares for fair market value plus interest (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). In practice, how might that work? Let’s say your appraiser finds that your business was actually worth $120,000 when the plan bought 100% of the shares for $100,000. That means the plan underpaid by $20,000. To correct it, your corporation could issue a payment (or promissory note) to the plan for $20,000, essentially “buying” additional stock value that the plan should have received. Alternatively, the company could issue additional shares to the plan to reflect the true value (though issuing more shares when the plan already owned 100% doesn’t change economics, so a cash infusion is usually needed). The correction should also include an interest factor (the IRS might use the plan’s presumed earnings rate or an official interest rate to calculate this), compensating the plan for not having had that $20,000 invested from the start.
Executing a correction can be financially challenging. If the amount is small, you might just pay it in. If it’s large, you may need to raise funds — possibly by contributing personal money, borrowing, or finding an outside investor (though bringing in an outside investor would itself require a proper valuation for their share!). The key is to document the correction clearly: corporate board resolutions, amended plan records, etc., showing the plan received the additional consideration.
4. Report and Pay Any Excise Taxes Due: If a prohibited transaction did occur (and it did, if you underpaid), you are technically required to report it and pay the 15% excise tax. This is done on IRS Form 5330. Often, when people self-correct, they will file Form 5330 and pay the 15% to close the loop. This shows the IRS you are coming clean. If you’re going through a correction program, your advisor will instruct you on timing (sometimes you can get IRS to waive penalties under VCP if you agree to correction and pay excise). But it’s safer to assume you should pay the 15% excise tax on the amount involved. It hurts, but it’s far less costly than waiting and risking 100%. By doing so, you start the clock on the “correction period” and demonstrate good faith. For example, using our $20,000 difference, 15% is $3,000. You’d send that to the IRS with an explanation of the transaction. If the IRS later audits, you can show that not only did you fix the problem (gave the plan the $20k plus interest), but you also paid the required penalty tax. That could go a long way toward avoiding further sanctions.
5. Amend Plan Documents if Necessary: If your plan document or corporate actions contributed to the issue (for instance, if there was some plan clause that inadvertently caused a violation, or if you had prevented other employees from participating contrary to plan terms), work with your advisors to amend them. Ensure that the plan doesn’t have any provisions that violate rules (the IRS has cited plans that were amended to stop others from buying stock, which is a problem (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service)). You want your paperwork to be squeaky clean going forward. Adopt any needed plan amendments to clarify that all investments (and any future stock transactions) will be at fair market value, and that employees will be treated fairly.
6. Going Forward – Adhere to Compliance Strictly: After addressing the immediate undervaluation, make sure to institute best practices to prevent recurrence. This means getting annual valuations of the company stock for the plan. Hire a professional each year or at least periodically to appraise the business, or use a robust method to estimate the value if minor changes. This not only helps with required reporting (Form 5500, participant statements) but also keeps you informed if the business’s value is rising – which you need to know if you plan to eventually buy the shares out or bring in new investors. Treat the plan as an outside investor — it deserves to know the true value of its holdings. Also, ensure you file all required forms (like Form 5500 each year, which ROBS plans must file because the plan, not an individual, owns the business (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service)).
If the valuation issue arose because your ROBS promoter or advisor gave bad advice (e.g., “just use the rollover amount as the value”), you might consider speaking with an attorney about recourse. Some ROBS providers have been known to be overly lax on this step. While that doesn’t absolve you in the IRS’s eyes, you may have a claim if you face penalties due to their negligence. However, your immediate focus should be on fixing the issue for the IRS; any action against the promoter would come later.
By taking these steps, you significantly increase your chances of keeping your ROBS plan intact and avoiding the worst outcomes. The process essentially boils down to: (a) find out the true value, (b) make the plan whole for any shortfall, (c) pay any due penalties, and (d) tighten up compliance going forward. While no one wants to discover a mistake, being proactive and forthright can turn a potentially ruinous situation into a manageable one.
Of course, the ideal scenario is not having an undervaluation issue in the first place. Whether you’re just considering a ROBS or you’ve corrected one and are moving on, here are some best practices to keep your ROBS compliant and your Business Valuation on target:
1. Always Use a Qualified Appraiser for Initial Valuation: When setting up a ROBS, do not skimp on the Business Valuation. Hire a credentialed Business Valuation professional (with certifications such as ASA or CVA). Provide them with all the information about your new business — business plans, financial projections, market research, assets being transferred, etc. A good appraiser will document how they arrived at the valuation. This report becomes your strongest defense if the IRS inquires. It shows that you sought “adequate consideration” in good faith. Even if the business is essentially just an idea and a bank account on day one, the appraiser will note that and typically the valuation will equal the cash injected (minus maybe startup costs). The key is it’s done independently and according to accepted standards.
2. Document Everything: Keep meticulous records of the ROBS transaction. This includes the corporate board resolution authorizing the stock issuance to the 401(k) plan for X dollars per share, the appraisal report justifying that price, the rollover paperwork, etc. Also document any discussions or decisions about valuation. If you as the founder put in any personal money or sweat equity outside of the rollover, document how that was treated (for example, did you receive additional shares outside the plan for that contribution? If so, make sure those shares were also issued at fair market value, so you’re not getting a better deal than the plan or vice versa).
3. Don’t Peg Value to Retirement Balance: It might be tempting to just set the valuation equal to what you have in your retirement account — e.g., “I have $250k, so I’ll value the business at $250k for 100% of the stock.” Avoid this simplistic approach. Instead, let the valuation drive the transaction. Maybe the fair value comes out to $200k and you roll $200k, leaving $50k in your IRA. Or maybe it’s $300k, in which case rolling only $250k would mean your plan owns only a portion of the stock and you’d need other funding for the rest. The point is, do not force the valuation to match your available funds; that’s backwards and obvious to regulators. If there’s a gap between your available retirement money and the fair value of the business, address it by either not rolling every penny (keep some funds in your IRA) or by supplementing the investment with outside funds. Let the valuation be determined independently, then structure your funding around it.
4. Regular Valuations and Monitor Company Value: As mentioned, get a valuation periodically. Each year when preparing the plan’s Form 5500 (or 5500-EZ for one-participant plans) and financial statement, update the value of the stock. You might obtain a professional appraisal every year or perhaps do one every couple of years with estimates in between. If the business is growing, don’t hide it. That’s a good thing — your retirement plan benefits too. Yes, a higher valuation might mean that if you want to buy the stock back personally later, it’ll cost you more, but that’s a future concern and a positive one (it means your business succeeded). Compliance-wise, reporting the proper value annually keeps you honest and in the clear. It also ensures that if you ever need to take RMDs or do an exit transaction, you have an up-to-date and defensible figure.
5. Plan for an Exit Strategy Early: If you eventually want to dissolve the ROBS structure (i.e., have the company or yourself buy out the 401(k)’s shares), plan how you’ll fund that buyout. Perhaps set aside some of the business’s profits or arrange financing when the time comes. When you do decide to execute the buyout, get a valuation for that transaction (just as you did at setup). That way, the exit stock sale is also at fair market value, preventing a prohibited transaction on the way out. A well-planned exit strategy will also consider tax implications (for instance, if the plan sells shares at a gain, those gains remain in the plan tax-deferred). The key is to approach the buyout with the same diligence as the initial rollover.
6. Engage Knowledgeable Advisors: Use CPAs, attorneys, or consultants who specialize in ROBS for ongoing support. Not all financial or legal advisors are familiar with the nuances of ROBS compliance. Working with specialists (like ROBS-experienced CPA firms or firms like SimplyBusinessValuation.com for valuations) can ensure you stay on top of IRS rules and deadlines. They can assist with plan administration tasks (like timely 5500 filings, plan updates for law changes, etc.) and advise you before you take any actions that might inadvertently cause a problem. The cost of professional advice is far less than the cost of a mistake that triggers IRS penalties.
By following these best practices, you significantly reduce the risk of your Business Valuation being called into question. In essence, treat the transaction with the same rigor and fairness as you would if you were dealing with an unrelated outside investor. The more arm’s-length and well-documented it is (even though it’s your own retirement money, you must act as if it isn’t), the safer you are.
Navigating the complexities of ROBS valuations and compliance can be daunting, especially for small business owners who are not valuation experts, or for CPAs who may not have dealt with ROBS-specific nuances. This is where SimplyBusinessValuation.com becomes an invaluable partner. As a professional Business Valuation service, SimplyBusinessValuation.com is well-equipped to help entrepreneurs and financial professionals handle the valuation requirements of ROBS, ensuring everything is done by the book.
1. Expert ROBS Business Valuations: SimplyBusinessValuation.com specializes in providing thorough, defensible business valuations. Our team understands the IRS’s expectations for ROBS transactions. When you engage our services for a ROBS valuation, we conduct a comprehensive analysis of your startup or business acquisition. We consider all relevant factors — from tangible assets to market conditions to income projections — to arrive at a fair market value. Importantly, we document our methodology and findings in a detailed report. Having a robust valuation report in hand means you can confidently show that your 401(k) plan paid a fair price for the stock, satisfying the “adequate consideration” requirement (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). This can dramatically reduce the risk of IRS scrutiny or give you a strong defense if questions arise.
2. Guidance on Compliance and Fairness: Our services don’t stop at just crunching numbers. At SimplyBusinessValuation.com, we educate clients on how to structure the transaction in alignment with valuation findings. For example, if our appraisal indicates the business is worth less or more than you expected, we guide you on what that means for your ROBS funding. We might advise you to roll over a slightly different amount or bring in additional funds if needed to reflect the true value. Because we have experience with ROBS cases, we’re familiar with the common mistakes to avoid. Our guidance can help you steer clear of undervaluation or overvaluation traps from the outset.
3. Support for Financial Professionals: We also work closely with CPAs, attorneys, and business advisors who have clients using ROBS. SimplyBusinessValuation.com can be the trusted valuation arm for your advisory team. By collaborating with us, you can ensure that the advice you give your clients about their ROBS is backed by authoritative valuation data. This not only protects the client but also enhances your service offering. We understand that as a CPA or advisor, your reputation is on the line when guiding a client through a ROBS. Having a valuation expert on board (us) helps you provide holistic advice with confidence.
4. Assistance in Correcting Valuation Issues: If you or your client is already in a situation where the business may have been undervalued, SimplyBusinessValuation.com can step in to help rectify the situation. We can perform retroactive valuations (valuing the business as of the time of the original transaction) to determine how far off the original number was. With that information, we can then work with your legal/tax advisors to recommend a correction plan. We provide the factual foundation needed to fix the issue. As a neutral third party, our valuation can carry weight with the IRS as an independent assessment. We can even supply expert letters or support during an IRS audit to explain the valuation approach, if needed.
5. Ongoing Valuation Services: For ROBS-funded businesses that are up and running, SimplyBusinessValuation.com offers ongoing valuation services. We can update your company’s valuation annually or at whatever interval is appropriate. This ensures your plan’s records stay current and compliant. When it’s time for required minimum distributions or if you plan to buy back the stock, we can perform a fresh valuation to facilitate that transaction correctly. By having a consistent valuation partner, you build a track record of compliance. In any interaction with regulators or potential investors, you can show a history of independent valuations, underscoring the legitimacy of your financial practices.
6. Education and Resources: We pride ourselves on not just delivering a service, but also educating our clients. SimplyBusinessValuation.com is developing a library of resources (like this article) to help demystify business valuations, especially in specialized contexts like ROBS. We aim to be a go-to knowledge source for business owners and professionals. If you have questions or uncertainties, feel free to reach out through our website. We’re happy to answer questions and point you toward solutions, even if you’re just in the exploratory phase.
In summary, SimplyBusinessValuation.com is here to make sure that “valuation” is the last thing you need to worry about in your ROBS transaction. By entrusting us with the valuation process, you can focus on building your business, while we ensure the numbers and compliance aspects hold up under scrutiny. We bring not only technical expertise in valuation but also a deep understanding of the regulatory backdrop (IRS and ERISA rules) that make ROBS unique. Our professional, trustworthy approach reinforces your credibility — whether you’re an entrepreneur defending your plan’s integrity or a CPA firm safeguarding a client’s compliance.
With a partner like SimplyBusinessValuation.com, you have a safety net. We help catch issues early, and we help resolve them when they occur. This way, the powerful benefits of a ROBS (accessing your retirement funds to fuel your business) can be enjoyed without undue fear of the valuation being “too low” and causing a problem. We stand ready to assist you in navigating these waters with confidence and precision.
Remember: a ROBS is a powerful way to fund a business with your retirement money, but it demands careful compliance. Ensuring the company is properly valued—neither under nor overvalued—is key to maintaining the arrangement’s legality and benefits. With the right knowledge and support, you can leverage a ROBS safely. SimplyBusinessValuation.com is here to ensure you’re on solid ground with your Business Valuation, so you can focus on building your venture. In the next section, we address some frequently asked questions to further clarify concerns about low valuations in ROBS.
Now that we have covered the main content, let’s address some common questions and misconceptions about low business valuations in a ROBS setup. This Q&A section will reinforce the key points in a concise format.
Q1: What does it mean for a Business Valuation to be “too low” in a ROBS, and how do I recognize it?
A1: A “too low” valuation means the appraised worth of your business (usually the price at which your 401(k) plan purchases the stock) is significantly below its fair market value. In a ROBS, you might suspect a valuation is too low if it was simply set equal to the amount of your retirement funds with no independent analysis, or if a cursory appraisal gave a value that doesn’t match the business’s assets or realistic potential. For example, if your new corporation had $100,000 in cash from the rollover and no other assets or operations, a valuation drastically lower than $100,000 would be questionable (why would it be worth less than its cash?). Essentially, you recognize an undervaluation when common sense and proper valuation methods indicate the company should be worth more than the number used in the transaction. Getting an independent valuation is the surest way to know — the professional will estimate fair market value. If that fair market value is higher than the price your plan paid, the business was undervalued for ROBS purposes.
Q2: Why is an undervalued ROBS business such a big deal?
A2: It violates the very rules that make ROBS legal. If your plan pays less than fair market value for the stock, the deal fails the “adequate consideration” test (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups) and becomes a prohibited transaction. That in turn can trigger excise taxes (15% of the amount involved, potentially rising to 100% if not corrected) (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). In the worst case, the IRS can disqualify your plan, meaning your rolled-over funds would become taxable as if you took an early distribution (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service). In essence, undervaluation is seen as cheating your own retirement fund, so it raises red flags (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups) and can unravel the tax-free benefit of the ROBS.
Q3: Is overvaluing the business also a problem, or only undervaluing?
A3: Undervaluation is the primary concern because the law forbids the plan from paying less than fair market value (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). Overvaluing (paying too much) doesn’t break that specific rule, but it’s still not good — it means your 401(k) overpaid for the stock, which wastes your retirement money. If overvaluation were done intentionally to pull more cash out, it could draw IRS scrutiny, but generally undervaluation is the bigger compliance issue. The goal should always be an accurate valuation, neither too low nor too high.
Q4: How can the IRS tell if my Business Valuation was too low?
A4: Primarily by looking at your documentation (or lack thereof). If your valuation conveniently equals the amount of your rollover and you can’t produce a solid appraisal report to justify it, that’s a red flag. IRS examiners have noted many ROBS plans where the “valuation” was just a one-page statement matching the retirement account balance (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). In a compliance check or audit, they will ask how you set the stock price (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service). If you can’t substantiate it with a bona fide valuation, the IRS will conclude that the number was arbitrarily low.
Q5: My ROBS provider set up my plan and valuation; if something’s wrong, am I liable or are they?
A5: You are ultimately responsible. Even if a ROBS provider handled the setup, the IRS views you (the plan sponsor and fiduciary) as accountable for compliance. If the valuation was too low, it’s on you and your company’s plan to correct it and face any taxes or penalties. You could later seek recourse from the provider for bad advice, but that doesn’t stop the IRS from coming after your plan. In short, using a provider doesn’t shift liability – you must exercise due diligence (like getting a proper appraisal) to protect yourself.
Q6: Can I fix an undervalued ROBS transaction after the fact?
A6: Yes, absolutely—and the sooner the better. The remedy is to make the plan whole for the shortfall. Typically, your corporation (or you as owner) must contribute the missing amount of value (plus a reasonable interest for lost earnings) to the 401(k) plan (Guidelines regarding rollover as business start-ups). This effectively brings the stock purchase up to fair market value after the fact. You’ll also need to report the prohibited transaction and pay the 15% excise tax on the amount involved (usually via IRS Form 5330). By correcting promptly, you avoid the 100% penalty and greatly reduce the chance of plan disqualification. It’s wise to do this with guidance from a tax professional and to document everything (the payment, a new valuation, etc.). The IRS is much more forgiving when they see you’ve proactively fixed the issue.
Q7: Will correcting the valuation mistake protect my plan from disqualification?
A7: Almost certainly. The IRS generally prefers plans to be corrected rather than disqualified. If you’ve made the plan whole and paid the necessary excise taxes, the IRS has little reason to take the extreme step of disqualifying your plan. They usually reserve disqualification for egregious cases or when a problem is ignored. Assuming undervaluation was the main issue and you fixed it in good faith, you are very likely to avoid plan disqualification. Demonstrating cooperation and correction goes a long way toward keeping your plan qualified.
Q8: Do I need to get my business valued every year after a ROBS, or just at the start?
A8: Yes, you should update the valuation periodically, not just at the start. Each year, your 401(k) plan needs an updated value for its assets for reporting purposes. You might not require a full professional appraisal every single year if the business hasn’t changed much, but you should at least make a reasonable estimate annually and get a formal valuation every few years (or whenever the business changes significantly). Also keep in mind that when someone in the plan must take required minimum distributions (at age 72), you’ll need an accurate value to calculate those. In short, regular valuations are advisable to ensure ongoing compliance and to track how your investment is doing.
Q9: If my business fails and becomes worthless, was my initial valuation a problem?
A9: No. If your business becomes worthless due to business circumstances, that doesn’t mean the initial valuation was a problem — as long as the valuation was fair at the time of the ROBS transaction. The IRS won’t penalize you just because the business lost value after the fact; they care that the stock purchase price was fair on day one. Many ROBS-funded businesses do fail (Rollovers as business start-ups compliance project | Internal Revenue Service), and that’s treated as an investment loss in your 401(k) plan, not a compliance violation. As long as you followed the rules initially, a later business failure is not an IRS issue (beyond the unfortunate loss of your retirement money). In short, a failed business doesn’t retroactively prove the valuation was wrong — it’s just part of the risk of entrepreneurship.
Q10: How can SimplyBusinessValuation.com help me avoid or fix valuation problems in my ROBS?
A10: SimplyBusinessValuation.com helps ensure your ROBS valuation is done correctly and stays compliant. We provide independent business appraisals before you implement a ROBS, giving you a reliable fair market value and a detailed report that will satisfy IRS requirements. If you’ve already executed a ROBS and are unsure about the valuation, we can review your figures and provide a fresh, independent valuation analysis. If it turns out your business was undervalued, we’ll quantify the shortfall and work with your CPA or attorney on steps to correct it. We also offer ongoing support — performing annual or periodic valuations for your ROBS-funded business (for plan reporting or when you’re ready to buy out the 401(k)’s shares) — to ensure every stage of the ROBS remains at fair market value. In short, by partnering with us, you gain seasoned valuation experts who understand the IRS’s expectations for ROBS. We help protect your retirement assets and keep your plan in the IRS’s good graces. With SimplyBusinessValuation.com’s support, you can confidently pursue a ROBS funding strategy knowing the valuation aspect won’t be a weak link.
